Court dismisses solar developer's complaint against town
Attorney Merrill Bent, representing both the town and Bennington County Regional Commission in the matter, had filed a motion to dismiss in March, contending in part that the appeal and complaint were not proper for the venue. In a decision released Wednesday afternoon, the court agreed.
"The Environmental Court ruled that the plaintiffs brought their claims in the wrong court," Bent said. "The plaintiffs already knew that, because we told them that when they filed this case. It appears that the plaintiffs are focused on burning taxpayer dollars, not on what the law says."
In February, a limited liability corporation related to the solar developer challenged the adoption of Bennington's new Energy Plan, contending that it did not comply with provisions of Chapter 117, the state's 2016 energy planning legislation, and that it violated the developer's constitutional rights.
Chapter 117 is intended to give more deference before the Public Utility Commission to communities over the siting of large energy projects.
Allco Renewable Energy has at least three commercial solar projects in the planning or permitting stages for sites in Bennington. A company spokesman said Wednesday afternoon that further appeals are likely concerning the energy siting issues raised in the Environmental Court complaint.
The town Energy Plan, which in part identifies preferred areas of town where energy facilities should be located, also was approved in March by the BCRC members.
Third court venue
The developer had filed a civil suit in Chittenden County Superior Court in January, setting forth similar challenges and naming the town, BCRC and several local officials and residents.
At the town's request that suit was removed to U.S. District in February, in part because it included constitutional rights allegations. However, two days later, the developer asked to dismiss its own action and then filed a similar complaint in Environmental Court.
"This is one of several examples of the sustained efforts to beat the town into submission through expense," Bent, of Woolmington, Campbell, Bent & Stasny, the town's legal firm, said Wednesday afternoon.
"It is one thing for them to spend their own money on baseless suits, but it is shameful to waste taxpayer dollars rather than just following municipal regulations like everyone else," she said.
In a decision signed by Judge Thomas G. Walsh, the Environmental Court also denied a request from the plaintiffs to transfer the case back to Superior Court, where it began in January.
Thomas Melone, the CEO of Allco Renewable Energy, said Wednesday afternoon in an email: "The issues involving the Bennington Town Plan are important ones. [A Bennington resident] put it succinctly at last Monday's Select Board meeting: the town is trying to take away property rights without just compensation."
The developer's complaint in Environmental Court was filed by the firm, Paul Frank & Collins, of Burlington.
Reached via email, Bennington Town Manager Stuart Hurd said Wednesday, "We are pleased with the outcome. It is unfortunate that litigation is the chosen method of communication."
The town's energy plan — a 28-page amendment to the larger town plan — was developed by the town Planning Commission with the assistance of a citizen group and town and BCRC staff members, before being recommended in November to the Select Board for approval. Both town boards approved it unanimously.
The developer also had sought an injunction against the BCRC against certifying either the town energy plan or a recent town screening ordinance for energy facilities. And Allco Renewable challenged the constitutionality of the state delegating authority to approve energy plans to a regional commission under provisions of Act 174.
Jim Therrien writes for New England Newspapers in Southern Vermont and VTDigger.org. Email: email@example.com. @BB_therrien on Twitter.
TALK TO US
If you'd like to leave a comment (or a tip or a question) about this story with the editors, please email us. We also welcome letters to the editor for publication; you can do that by filling out our letters form and submitting it to the newsroom.