Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.



As part of plea agreement, Pownal defendant in national scam agrees to leave US, pay restitution

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.  

PITTSFIELD, Mass. — It was the start of the pandemic, and Gary M. had just been laid off from his job. Worst of all, a close family member had just passed away.

It was then that he got a phone call from someone who told him his personal information had been stolen by bad actors, who committed crimes in his name. As a result, there were warrants out for Gary’s arrest, said the caller, who pledged to help Gary M. sort through the mess.

The disabled Philadelphia resident mailed 23-year-old Parth “Peter” Chaudhari thousands in cash, said Assistant District Attorney Heather Valentine, not knowing that the warrants were phony, the whole story made up.

He had become one of at least nine known victims of a complex phone scam last year that prosecutors said relied on the emotional manipulation to bilk people in seven states out of about $300,000.

On Tuesday, Chaudhari, of Pownal, Vt., received judgement for the scheme, pleading guilty before Judge John Agostini to single counts of larceny over $1,200 by single scheme and attempting to commit larceny over $1,200 by single scheme.

A call, a ruse, and guilt: ‘Known Victim’ in alleged scam with Pownal ties offers warning

Chaudhari admitted to using similar phone scams to extract hundreds of thousands of dollars from victims through a scheme that unfolded locally, at locations including the Express Smoke & Vape Shop in Adams.

Defense attorney Elizabeth Quigley and Valentine jointly recommended a sentence of time served for Chaudhari and restitution. Quigley said Chaudhari will also “self-deport” as early as next week to India, where his family lives outside of Mumbai.

For Gary M., what followed after the calls were months of sleepless nights, the impact of losing his life savings. The emotional toll was “immeasurable,” he said.

So down on himself was Gary M., he said in a victim impact statement Valentine read in Berkshire Superior Court on Tuesday afternoon, that he considered suicide.

“I worked hard for every dime that was taken from me. I am not rich by any means, and every dollar matters,” he said.

Gary M. said he ultimately received professional help from a therapist, after confiding in his supportive sisters about his ordeal. He expressed empathy for those who have also been victims of such scams.

Support our journalism. Subscribe today. →

“If someone was affected by the same crime,” he said, according to Valentine, “I would like to tell them what happened to me, and help them to not beat themselves up.”

Chaudhari served almost eight months in pretrial incarceration before his release from custody on $100,000 cash bail, according to the clerk’s office.

As part of a plea deal with prosecutors, Chaudhari’s bail, which was posted by his uncle, will be converted to restitution next week, after which point his criminal sentencing is expected to be finalized.

Chaudhari will pay an additional $20,000, for total restitution of $120,000 that Valentine said will eventually be disbursed to the victims.

Authorities say alleged fraud ring with ties to Berkshires terrorized, isolated victims from family

“I think this money will in some small measure compensate the victims, although nothing can compensate them for their dignity, for their peace of mind, for their psychological well-being,” said Quigley.

Criminal cases are still pending in Berkshire Superior Court against two other defendants, cousins Jitendra Chaudhari, of Williamstown, and Ajaykumar Chaudhari, of Pownal, Vt.

The locally run scam, said Quigley, was a “small part of a much larger” criminal enterprise centered in the Chicago area. Those defendants were prosecuted in federal court, she said.

Berkshire County prosecutors say the Chaudharis targeted mostly seniors from as far away as California and Oklahoma, using fear and personal information to frighten potential victims into sending cash to various addresses, mostly in the Berkshires.

Valentine read a second victim impact statement written by a nurse of 38 years, who said the defendants manipulated her out of about $200,000. She said her life treating pediatric patients is marked by compassion, and expressed gratitude for Adams police Detective Michael Wandrei, who spearheaded the investigation.

“I daily pray for those involved in this crime,” the nurse said.

Amanda Burke can be reached at or 413-496-6296.


If you'd like to leave a comment (or a tip or a question) about this story with the editors, please email us.
We also welcome letters to the editor for publication; you can do that by filling out our letters form and submitting it to the newsroom.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.