| D.C. United | 0 | 2 | — | 2 |
| New York City FC | 2 | 1 | — | 3 |
First Half_1, New York City FC, Talles Magno, 1 (Cufre), 17th minute; 2, New York City FC, Rodriguez, 1 (Pereira), 37th.
Second Half_3, D.C. United, Benteke, 2 (Klich), 46th; 4, New York City FC, Thiago, 1 (Rodriguez), 88th; 5, D.C. United, Birnbaum, 1 (Klich), 90th+1.
Goalies_D.C. United, Tyler Miller, Alex Bono; New York City FC, Luis Barraza, Matt Freese.
Yellow Cards_Russell Canouse, D.C. United, 8th; Palsson, D.C. United, 49th; Rodriguez, New York City FC, 53rd; Jeahze, D.C. United, 58th; Pellegrini, New York City FC, 73rd.
Referee_Mark Allatin. Assistant Referees_Andrew Bigelow, Matthew Nelson, Sorin Stoica. 4th Official_Christopher Penso.
Lineups
D.C. United_Tyler Miller; Steven Birnbaum, Mohanad Jeahze (Matai Akinmboni, 60th), Ruan (Jacob Greene, 46th), Derrick Williams; Chris Durkin, Mateusz Klich, Theodore Ku-DiPietro, Russell Canouse (Victor Palsson, 46th); Christian Benteke, Nigel Robertha (Pedro Santos, 46th, Yamil Asad, 78th).
New York City FC_Luis Barraza; Maxime Chanot, Brian Cufre, Tayvon Gray, Thiago Martins Bueno; Keaton Parks, Matias Pellegrini, Santiago Rodriguez, James Sands; Gabriel Pereira (Alfredo Morales, 69th), Talles Magno (Thiago, 80th).
